Bluesapalooza Remains Very Popular, But The Big Crowds Are Still Missing!

![]()
![]()
![]()
Market Summary – July 21 to August 4
Condominium Inventory
Single-Family Home Inventory
Pending Transactions
Market Updates and News
Bluesapalooza (and The Festival of Beers) has become the major event of the Mammoth summer and the new promoter has brought the event venue to the most impressive level yet, and this year it included two stages for almost non-stop live performances. The event has been plagued with smoke and rain in the past but this year it was just a bit of light showers (and cooler temperatures) on Friday with little impact to the event. In the past the event has been sold out ahead of time but this year a variety of tickets and packages appeared available through the weekend. Overall, Mammoth tourism remains subdued in the summer of 2024.
Phase 1 of the Snowcreek Phase 8 tentative map is currently (and quietly) on the Planning Commission’s agenda. By acreage, Phase 8 is 40% of the entire Snowcreek master plan. This is the Town’s opportunity to exact/extract from the developer and development, but the effort seems benign. The Town doesn’t even seem interested in hiring a consultant to advise them on improving on the existing development agreement. The Town is asking for an open space agreement for the existing Snowcreek golf course and some sort of guarantee for the course’s continued operation. There are 47 “affordable housing” units planned within the development but the triggers for performance and development of them appear nebulous. Mammoth has a long history of requiring these units at this stage of the process and then never actually seeing them get built. Phase 1 of the development is proposed to include clustered residential buildings facing into the golf course where the existing clubhouse is and a realignment of Hole #1.

Meanwhile, the Planning Commission will have three (out of five) newly seated Commissioners for the next meeting. One is a former Commissioner, one is an active real estate agent in Mammoth, and one is a complete unknown. My advice would be to not rush this Snowcreek 8 proposal and approvals. It needs to be vetted and there isn’t going to be any construction happening in 2024 anyway.
The new Sawyer building at The Parcel will finally have an official ribbon cutting this week. We’ll see if it is performative or if they will actually start moving members of the Mammoth workforce into units. Between the new ~100 units of workforce housing coming on line, the new subsidized program promoted by Placemate, and the natural economic progression of some STR properties turning into long-term rentals, there may be a significant supply of long-term rentals available this fall. That could be an interesting market condition.
The Town placed an electronic sign out in front of my office on Old Mammoth Road that read “Bikes Must Follow All Traffic Laws, Enforced By Citation.” It certainly did nothing to curtail the continued e-bike craziness, but at least someone is recognizing that it is becoming a real problem….I see The Auto Club (AAA) is offering an e-bike course for teens. This seems a bit discriminatory. I could propose a class for out-of-shape, middle-aged people who haven’t been on a bike in years who also think they can ride without any situational awareness. This class should be a requirement before renting an e-bike in Mammoth.
The new and redeveloped workforce housing units are all coming in at ~$1M per unit. Even the smallest units. So I asked myself; What is in the condo inventory at around $1M? There’s a townhome at Chateau Tyrol for $925,000—modern 3 bedroom/ 3 bath with a 2 -car garage. Low HOA fee. A great “missing middle” property available on the open market. At $999,000 there is a 2 bedroom / 2 bath, 1-car garage townhome in Snowcreek 5. Or how about a 2 bedroom + loft / 2 bath, 1-car garage townhome in the center of town for $799,000? And way more affordable is a 1 bedroom + loft / 2 bath, 1-car garage unit at Bigwood for only $599,000….Several years ago “they” switched the term “affordable housing” to “workforce housing.” Now we know why—their affordable housing was no longer affordable.
Noteworthy Sales
The penthouse 2 bedroom / 2 bath at the Westin Monache closed for $1,683,000 or $1,280 per square foot. Premier condo hotel units in the Village continue to perform at a high level.
A beautifully remodeled 3 bedroom / 3 bath, 1-car garage townhome in Snowcreek 5 closed for $1,425,000. Impressive. These are popular floorplans with lots of windows, views and natural light. They have appreciated nicely over the past four years, and this is a new high.
Other Real Estate News
My discussions about the rapidly coming changes (August 15 here in California) in the real estate industry may seem like beating a dead horse, but the changes are profound and there is going to be a good deal of confusion. Buyers and sellers are already being influenced by misinformation. And despite what many in the industry think, there are not going to be any simple “workarounds” to create a similar situation to the past. The legal profession, both on the public and private side, are going to be watching for non-compliance and ultimately liability. And inevitably, they are going to be salivating for industry participants to snitch on each other.
The buyer side is where the most changes are, so let’s get into more specifics and what prospective buyers can now expect. The most significant mechanical change is that any and all buyers will need to have a “Representation Agreement” signed with a broker or agent in order to be shown a listed property. Public open houses, which are so popular in SoCal, fall into some different rules. But real potential buyers and looky-loos alike attending open houses will be registering and signing a variety of disclosures based on the listing brokerage’s policies (this will likely evolve into a facial photo registration too…gotta get these facial recognition databases involved).
For non-open house purposes, like most of the Mammoth market, agents will need a signed Representation Agreement in order to show any listed property. These will come in two variations; essentially a long-form and a short-form. Both will clearly spell out a compensation level for the buyer’s agent that the buyer shall be responsible for paying at the close of any related escrow (potential buyers have yet to wrap their heads around this). My conjecture is that the short form, know as form PSRA, will become popular in Mammoth. It is the “one night stand” of a buyer/agent relationship. The agreed relationship cannot last for more than 30 days and allows for the agent to show a maximum of three properties, which need to be listed on the form (pencils with erasers may become valuable again). Most agents will inevitably have a small stack of these forms laying around (we had a similar form back during Covid lockdowns known as the PEAD—it was the necessary evil required to show a property.)

The longer form known as the Buyer Representation and Broker Compensation Agreement (form BRBC) will be used for longer-term and more committed relationships. This can have a longer term, but still cannot exceed 90 days. It too commits the buyer to compensating the buyer’s agent, but also delves into the buyer’s preferences, qualifications, and even the ability to pay for their agent’s compensation. This form and standard of practice is where most of the industry and the real estate coaches see the opportunity for agents to “sell” their value in the process. Buyer’s agents are going to have to prove their value in this new paradigm. And buyers are also going to have to show some minor allegiance. For agents, it could also ultimately determine whether a buyer gets hired or fired.
None of these new requirements and forms mean that there can’t be (extensive) conversations between a buyer and a broker/agent prior to actually looking at property. This is often the norm in Mammoth. There can be many months of discussions, etc.. prior to actually looking at property. Prospective buyers may actually, and prudently, spend a bit more time consulting with their future agent.
I see both of the above mentioned forms being used in the Mammoth market. But less desperate agents are likely to shun away from PSRA-type buyers. The true professional agents will pursue BRBC buyers that they can cultivate a longer-term and committed relationship with. These forms will also be required to be submitted with any offers to purchase to verify the buyer representation status and compensation level. All of this is happening at an interesting time in the market, as the “impulsiveness” of the past few years wanes, buyers are becoming far more scrutinizing of each and every real estate offering.
Does all of this mean that this is the end of sellers offering to compensate the buyer’s agent in a transaction? No. But the “sub-agency” arrangement of the previous decades is now over. Any type of “commission sharing” arrangement will be a serious liability. Any type of mechanism that even hints at it will only exacerbate the liability. For some agents and brokers, this is a tough pill to swallow.
Once a “represented” buyer gets to making a formal offer, the new standardized offer will (most likely) include a “Seller Payment To Buyer’s Broker” form. Based on the listing agent’s discussions and preparation of the seller, the seller should be expecting this request for compensation. This is some of the great unknowns of the future—how will all of this operate? (And it may operate differently in different markets?) Will sellers now refuse to compensate the buyer’s agent who is trying to sell their property? In 2021 or 2022 they may have thought that way. Today, maybe not so much. Sellers may or will want to offer incentives. Or will the sellers want to negotiate the compensation? Time will tell. Everything is negotiable (always has been).
Buyers will also have the option to reject offers/counteroffers that do no cover their committed level of compensation to their agent. Many buyers may find themselves negotiating for their own price and terms, but for the compensation amount of their agent too. Of course, their agent will really be doing the negotiating, but negotiating the buyer’s agent compensation is all new territory. In the past it was written in stone, and not anymore. And that is what this is all about.
The buyers will be looking at the terms of the negotiation with new interest. Not only the ultimate sales price but what the Buyer’s agent agreement says towards compensation and what the seller has agreed to credit (the “concession”) the transaction for it. And will buyers reject offers/counteroffers from sellers because their commitment to their agent isn’t covered? I’m guessing most will. And does this create new friction between the buyer and their agent? It might. And it has even been suggested that buyers won’t even want to look at properties where sellers are not offering buyer broker compensation.
And then there will be buyers who will choose to represent themselves and “benefit” from the fact that there will be no compensation paid to a buyers agent. They will go direct to the seller’s agent. The new California-based listing agreements allow for the seller’s agent to receive additional compensation if they have to work with an unrepresented buyer. This is similar to what has happened in the past under these circumstances, except in the past the seller’s agent became a dual agent, representing both parties. How this scenario will be handled will be up to the seller. But for now, it appears there will be no dual agency. I expect unrepresented buyers to become more commonplace, at least in the short run. The whole thing could get murky. Buyer beware is alive and well.
Meanwhile the conventional lenders have already agreed that these compensation concessions will not affect lending. But this too could become a wildcard in the future.
In the coming months there will be casual and serious buyers caught off guard by these industry changes. Many will be confused. Some will think they can “take advantage” of the situation. It may take months or years to be sorted out and return to some level of normalcy, whatever that is going to be.
Thanks for reading!