Mammoth Prays For A Wet Spring And Real Estate Ebbs And Flows!

![]()
![]()
![]()
Market Summary – February 23 to March 23
This newsletter is for the past four weeks. Life can get in the way of newsletters, but this may become the more appropriate time frame for this newsletter in the future. I’ll see. This bi-weekly newsletter was founded some 15 years ago in the midst of a very active foreclosure/REO market—a truly interesting time that quickly morphed into a never-seen-before short sale market that ran parallel to the REO cycle and sales. The market lulled for a couple of years but it eventually rolled into the crazed post-Covid lockdown market. Today, higher interest rates and higher prices (and maybe sheer exhaustion) have reduced the transaction flow and newsworthy activity in the market (and community). In the future, I will remain focused on quality not quantity.
The Mammoth Lakes MLS is reporting 32 real estate closings for the period ranging from a low of $350,000 to a high of $3,800,000. Of the 32 closings, 30 were financeable properties and 10 were closed with financing. The sales included three (3) single family homes above $3M (winter continues to bring the luxury buyers to the market). Interestingly, all three are not located in the more modern luxury neighborhoods common with this price range. The high sale’s appeal—it is a true snowmobile-out and snowmobile-in property. There was another 3/3 Village condo hotel unit closing at $2.2M. There were eight (8) condo closings under $600,000. Mammoth remains a very mixed market. Also interesting, there were five (5) buyers represented by non-local MLS members—a higher than normal percentage. That tells me fewer buyers are appreciating local knowledge….This period last year there were 25 closings.
Condominium Inventory
Single-Family Home Inventory
Pending Transactions
Market Updates and News
A couple of fresh snow events during the period brought crowds to town but the overall weekend activity has been on the relative slow side. Despite sub-average snow totals on Mammoth Mountain, the coverage remains more than adequate—that is the beauty of Mammoth—it wrings the most out of even minimal storms. While winter is now gone from the calendar, April can still be a snowy month. Weather and tourism will be a crapshoot the next two months but the Ski Area will no doubt push for a Memorial Day closing
While The Sheet reported on the Creekhouse cell tower hearing in this weekend’s issue with nothing definitive, a reader and Creekhouse owner sent me this message on the 18th, “Just an update. Looks like we won our suit :). Judge made a preliminary ruling in our favor. Said in no stretch of the imagination is this a small structure allowing for a CEQA exemption. They only have two choices forward now, neither is very likely (appeal to another court and risk losing, but the loss being precedent, or reapply and pay $1,200,000 for an EIR).”

I haven’t verified this but it certainly makes sense. Mammoth is steeped in CEQA (California Environmental Quality Act) history. The Friends of Mammoth legal case was the first substantial court case under the Act. But Mammoth and the local planning and legal communities benefitted from attorney Jim Reed’s residence and practice in town for some ~30 years. Jim was one of the original authors of CEQA (while he was a professor at UC Davis circa the late 1960s) and an environmental law expert. He was an incredibly friendly and approachable man originally from rural Nevada. He taught me plenty about CEQA and real estate starting in the early 1990s. In this most recent Creekhouse case, Judge Mark Magit has been around long enough and would certainly have some of Reed’s influence. I would bet they even spoke about it at some point.
The sale of publicly held vacation rental company Vacasa ended up in a small bidding war. Since Vacasa’s entry into the Mammoth market they have been rather aggressive—if you happen to own a condo in Mammoth you have received plenty of solicitation mail from them in the past few years. My immediate observation (close to home) is that Vacasa has been very successful at higher than average occupancy rates. But they also apparently use aggressive dynamic pricing models in favor of the guests. But I don’t have any real data. It would be great to hear from some of their Mammoth owners. Looks like the new owner will be a privately held rental company based in Arizona.
Mammoth has a long history of rental company growth-by-acquisitions and sales. And some of it has been driven by simple retirements. And some of the “old guard” rental companies are today actually owned and operated by a second generation (with a third coming). But acquisition is the fastest way to grow to “scale” in the STR business. One presently operating Mammoth company founded their new brand by purchasing two sizable local companies and has built the subsequent company into a national presence. Along with acquiring other mom-and-pop rental companies across the country, they are now in the business of selling “franchises”, including the original Mammoth company. With the sale of Vacasa, I have to think more mergers and acquisitions will be in Mammoth’s future.
Two days ago from Calculated Risk, the hotel industry occupancy was down 3.5% YOY ending March 15. And revenue (REVPar) was down 4.2%. I think we are seeing this in Mammoth, or more so.
The Town’s housing project at the old Innsbruck Lodge on Forest Trail just down from the Village is open and should be fully occupied shortly. A total of 13 units. Some of these are sizable units. It will be interesting to see how this works out, it is a fairly compact property for this density. It was okay when guests were coming and going, but full-time living is a different story.
The media has been full of reports of burned-out lot sales in Pacific Palisades and Altadena. This is a fascinating market condition. Many see the demand as surprising (is for me). Many sellers are older and “don’t have time” for a rebuilding process. Some are desperate for money. Others are financially “right” by selling the land, taking their insurance proceeds and moving on. Other owners aren’t so fortunate because of insurance shortfalls, mortgages, etc.. The buying “investors” are taking a leap of faith. Some are being referred to as “sharks.” But only time will tell if the rebuild process is positive rationally, or economically. Values could certainly go down from here. Or the process could take far longer than expected (especially in Pacific Palisades where the Coastal Commission is involved).
What some of these investors might not be considering; the supply, or outright number of burned lots is quite substantial, even in a large metro area like LA. They might not be well informed about what it is really going to cost to rebuild, especially a “fireproof” home (and wait until contractors figure out the highest-bidder concept). Or they might be underestimating that the psychological factor of this event has hasn’t even sunk in for many of these property owners. This is going to be a interesting market to watch in the coming years. It seems early to be jumping in. The toxic clean-up hasn’t even really begun. Glad I don’t live downwind. And I found this article from the Malibu Times, the new “streamlined” process is already leaving property owners frustrated.
And lastly, one of the recently laid-off probationary employees was a new Yosemite National Park locksmith. It was his “dream job.” Locks at the tent camping? Maybe a variety of bear proof containers? I’m guessing leave early on Friday and show up late on Monday, and get in a bunch of great climbing in between. But anybody who knows “Bob the locksmith” in Mammoth knows the private side in this resort town is quite the opposite. He could truly work 24 hours a day. Amongst all the work, he is compelled to stay up on all of the latest keypad “resort lock” devices and their nuances. And maybe more importantly, be well educated and versed in all of the latest luxury vehicle ignition and safety devices—people drive their exotic, expensive vehicles into Mammoth and get into all sorts of predicaments. It is a thriving business in Mammoth.
Other Real Estate News
I’ll turn 66 years old this next week (I moved to Mammoth when I was 22) and many of my Mammoth peers are retiring or moving in that direction (as for me, nobody ever seems to “retire” from real estate until their phone stops ringing, and that hasn’t happened yet—I guess I’ll just have to change my number). But the retirement topic has always been in the air in the Mammoth real estate market. In the past 25 years many “boomer” era local purchasers have envisioned a quality retirement including spending time in the mountains. Some actually thought they would be here permanently. But the dynamics have changed in those 25 years and these changes appear to be part of the current demand we are seeing in the Mammoth market.
Back in 1996 when Intrawest came on the Mammoth scene, there was a very sophisticated sales apparatus that eventually “pre-sold” hundreds of units over the next 10 years. One of their big, driving sales premise was based on Harry S. Dent’s demographic book “The Great Boom Ahead”. The boomer generation was just reaching their “spending years” and owning a second home in a mountain resort community would be part of the program. Many of those buyers were also envisioning their retirement years too.
In my four decades of selling real estate in Mammoth, I can say that most buyers are always looking forward to spending more time in their Mammoth second home, and especially in their retirement years. And hopefully sharing it with their family and friends, especially their offspring. Many also see their properties becoming part of their “legacy” (the term has gone from an Intrawest marketing shtick to an actual life concept). And again, many actually saw themselves moving permanently to Mammoth in their retirement. But many unexpected realities have changed their plans. And these changes may likely be the driver of the continued and possibly increased demand we are seeing in the market.
One change is that many of these boomers are more affluent than they ever expected to be. Real estate appreciation, the stock market, inheritances, general inflation and more have made many in this generation incredibly wealthy. Many had outstanding careers or built wildly successful businesses. Meanwhile their primary residences have become tremendous assets, “comfortable”, and now in close proximity to their grandkids. Their wealth allows them to keep their primary residence and their second (or third or fourth) homes.

There is also the harsh reality that many of my Mammoth peers have discovered—living permanently in the Mammoth winter gets increasingly difficult as you get older. Being able to drive back-and-forth to Orange County in the winter makes an occasional snowstorm rather tolerable (or even novel). But dealing with it day-in-and-day-out can become tedious. Timing visits is a luxury, and convenient, and popular. For those in retirement age, it is almost a necessity. And forget it if you have lived in Mammoth for 40+ winters. And many have also discovered the desirability of Mammoth in the summer. The old saying about Mammoth; “come for the winter and stay for the summer.” Electric bikes make it all more enjoyable.
Some of these boomer era retirees are also utilizing the STR potential of properties to supplement their retirement income or to simply offset the Mammoth ownership costs. They don’t have to grind out a specific return on investment, but some rental income helps make sense of it all. And some have utilized 1031 exchanges to acquire these properties which makes the enjoyment factor even sweeter. And speaking of taxes, the long-term ownership of the property becomes almost compelling because of the eventual “stepped-up basis” of the property. For many, it cements the “legacy” factor for the property.
And now one more factor has emerged in the last few years. For Mammoth it is the IKON Pass. Sounds crazy but throughout my career I have heard the vision/dream that a Mammoth home would be the draw for the younger generations to come, stay, and interact with the older generations. Be it the holidays or random periods. The IKON Pass has now become the instrument to increase the likelihood for these events to happen. Especially if the grandkids get IKON Passes as presents. A Pass, a free place to stay, free meals, etc. is a small price to pay for hanging out with old people for a few days. And if they play their cards right, they might even be allowed to come without grandma and grandpa around. Mammoth’s proximity and drivability makes all this work on a whole different level.
Nobody saw this as a grand plan but it makes sense for the continued demand for properties including single-family homes and many townhome style condominiums. And many of these properties have little or no debt. As more and more boomers retire, more are going to consider this lifestyle as a very desirable path.
Thanks for reading!
Enjoyed reading the newsletter, very insightful!